New findings, published in The Lancet, have shown cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT)*, provided in addition to usual care, can reduce symptoms of depression and help improve patients’ quality of life.
This is the first large-scale trial to test the effectiveness of CBT — a type of talking psychotherapy — given in addition to usual care that includes antidepressants. The National Institute for Health Research Health Technology Assessment (NIHR HTA) Programme-funded CoBalT study aimed to determine the best ‘next step’ treatment for people whose depression had not responded to medication alone.
The CoBaIT team, comprising researchers from the Universities of Bristol, Exeter and Glasgow, recruited 469 patients aged 18- to 75-years with treatment-resistant depression for the randomised controlled trial. Patients were split into two groups: 235 patients continued with their usual care from the GP, which included continuing on antidepressant medication, and 234 patients were treated with CBT in addition to usual care from their GP. Researchers followed-up 422 patients (90 per cent) at six months and 396 (84 per cent) at 12 months to compare their progress.
At six months, 46 per cent of those who received CBT in addition to usual care had improved, reporting at least a 50 per cent reduction in symptoms of depression, compared to 22 per cent of those who continued with usual care alone. This beneficial effect was maintained over 12 months.
The findings demonstrate that CBT provided in addition to usual care including antidepressant medication is an effective treatment that reduces depressive symptoms, and improves the quality of life in patients whose depression has not responded to the most common first-line treatment for depression in primary care.
Dr Nicola Wiles, the study’s lead author and a Senior Lecturer in the University of Bristol’s School of Social and Community Medicine, said: “Antidepressants are often the first-line treatment for depression — a major public health problem with the World Health Organisation estimating that over 300 million people are affected globally. However, in many countries, access to psychological treatments such as CBT is limited to people who can afford to pay, or those with health insurance. These findings emphasise the importance of increasing the availability of psychological therapy. While there have been initiatives to increase access to such treatments in both the UK and Australia, worldwide initiatives are rare, and even in the UK many people who have not responded to antidepressants do not get psychological treatment. Our study suggests that by investing in psychological services it is possible to reduce the significant burden to patients and healthcare systems that is associated with non-response to antidepressant medication.
“Furthermore, it is important to acknowledge that while we found CBT was an effective treatment for this patient group, not everyone who received CBT improved. It is therefore essential that we invest in further research in this area to investigate alternative treatment options, both pharmacological and non-pharmacological, for the significant number of patients whose depression does not get better following treatment with antidepressants.“
Willem Kuyken, Professor of Clinical Psychology at the University of Exeter, added: “This trial provides further evidence that psychological treatments like cognitive therapy can provide substantive and lasting help to people who suffer depression. The Mood Disorders Centre, one of the participating sites, aims to make evidence-based psychological approaches as accessible as possible to people suffering depression. This trial demonstrates that people with complex and longstanding needs who have not responded to antidepressants can derive substantive and lasting benefit from CBT delivered by well trained therapists. Showing that 40 per cent of people who had been in cognitive therapy were largely free of symptoms at 12 months is really important because it bodes well for their longer-term recovery.”
John Campbell, Professor of General Practice at the University of Exeter Medical School, commented: “Depression is a very common illness, encountered frequently by GPs and their patients. While drug treatments can be very effective, not all patients will respond well to treatment. For some patients, the experience of depression can be particularly difficult. We were delighted that so many patients, GPs, and practices helped us with this research. The results we present today show that for some patients, the addition of a ‘talking therapy’ such as CBT can be very effective in treating the depression and helping resolve disabling symptoms. GPs and their patients can take real encouragement from these findings which provide real support for the use of CBT in patients where other treatments may have failed.”
Chris Williams, Professor of Psychosocial Psychiatry at the University of Glasgow, added: “This research is also of great importance because it used a CBT intervention alongside treatment with antidepressants. It confirms how these approaches — the psychological and physical — treatments can complement each other. It was also encouraging because we found the approach worked to good effect across a wide range of people of different ages and living in a variety of settings.”
Emer O’Neill, Chief Executive of Depression Alliance, the leading UK charity for people affected by depression, added: “Over the last few years there has been a significant improvement in lifting the stigma associated with depression, and the services available to help treat it.
“However, this marks just the beginning as for many years our members have been asking for access to a wide range of peer-support services. We are delighted to see this research as it now provides the evidence that a range of treatments such as cognitive behavioural therapy and medication is vital to continuing this success.”
1. WHO World Mental Health http://www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/fs369/en/index.html
2. *CBT involves a combination of cognitive and behavioural therapy and is a way of helping people with depression change the way they think in order to improve how they feel and to change what they do.
3. Paper: The National Institute for Health Research Health Technology Assessment[HTA]-funded CoBaIT study, entitled ‘Cognitive behavioural therapy as an adjunct to pharmacotherapy for primary care based patients with treatment resistant depression: results of the CoBalT randomised controlled trial’ by Nicola Wiles (1), Laura Thomas (1), Anna Abel (3), Nicola Ridgway (4), Nicholas Turner (1), John Campbell (5), Anne Garland (6), Sandra Hollinghurst (7), Bill Jerrom (8), David Kessler (7), Willem Kuyken (3), Jill Morrison (9), Katrina Turner (7), Chris Williams (4), Tim Peters (2), Glyn Lewis (1).
1. Centre for Mental Health, Addiction and Suicide Research, School of Social and Community Medicine, University of Bristol
2. School of Clinical Sciences, University of Bristol
3. Mood Disorders Centre, University of Exeter
4. Academic Unit of Mental Health and Wellbeing, Institute of Health and Wellbeing, University of Glasgow
5. Primary Care Research Group, University of Exeter Medical School
6. Nottingham Psychotherapy Unit, Nottinghamshire Healthcare NHS Trust
7. Centre for Academic Primary Care, School of Social and Community Medicine, University of Bristol
8. Avon and Wiltshire Mental Health Partnership NHS Trust
9. Institute of Health and Wellbeing, General Practice and Primary Care Group, University of Glasgow