Five studies were featured during an ACG press briefing on Tuesday, October 18, 2010 entitled: “Attack on C. difficile: A GI Perspective ‐ How We Can Combat this Serious Health Issue.”
C. difficile associated diarrhea (CDAD) is a major cause of morbidity and increasing health care costs among hospitalized patients, as C. difficile infections have dramatically increased in recent years, with 500,000 cases in the United States annually and approximately 15,000 deaths each year, according to the U.S. Centers for Disease Control & Prevention.
Proton Pump Inhibitors Linked to Incidence of C. difficile Associated Diarrhea
While antibiotic use is the most documented risk factor for CDAD, attention has been directed towards a plausible‐‐but controversial‐‐link with proton pump inhibitors (PPIs). Researchers today unveiled results of a meta‐analysis of 16 observational studies, which explored the association between CDAD and PPIs. The study, “A Meta‐analysis of 16 Observational Studies on Proton‐Pump Inhibitor Use and Risk of Clostridium difficile Associated Diarrhea” investigated the association between PPIs and CDAD from 1980‐2010 and involved more than 1.2 million hospitalized patients.
The investigators extracted adjusted risk estimates from the studies and used a random effects meta‐analysis. The summary risk estimate showed a 65 percent increase in the incidence of CDAD among PPI users, according to Sailajah Janarthanan, M.D., who co‐authored the study. Researchers also conducted a stratified analysis by study design and when looking at both prospective and retrospective studies, found that there was still a significant increase in C. difficile among PPI users.
The Introduction of National Hospital Quality Measures Linked to Rising C. difficile Rates
In 2004, the Joint Commission on Accreditation of Health Care Organizations (JCAHO) and the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) introduced National Hospital Quality Measures (NHQM) to improve pneumonia and surgical infection outcomes. However, these new quality measures have resulted in a substantial increase of antibiotic usage, which researchers hypothesized has led to an increase in C. difficile associated diarrhea and colitis in an inner city hospital in New York. As a result, researchers reviewed charts of all patients with confirmed C. difficile infection admitted to the Bronx Lebanon Hospital Center from January 1, 2003 to December 31, 2008. Antibiotic usage for all inpatients during the same time was also reviewed.
The study, “National Quality Measures and Clostridium difficile Infection in an Inner City Hospital,” found a total of 439 patients with confirmed C. difficile infection from January 1. 2003 to December 31, 2008.
“We observed significant increase in Clostridium difficile infection rate between 2003 and 2006,” said Ariyo Ihimoyan, M.D. The number of cases per 10,000 admissions was 16 in 2003; 20 in 2004; 50 in 2005; 36 in 2006; 40 in 2007; and 58 in 2008. The total number of antibiotic doses uses per 1000 admissions was 3268 in 2003; 3536 in 2004; 4585 in 2005; 5150 in 2006; 5848 in 2007; and 5867 in 2008.
“From these findings, we conclude that the introduction of National Hospital Quality Measures have led to a substantial increase in antibiotic usage,” said Dr. Ihimoyan. “We believe this resulted in an increase in Clostridium difficile infections in our patient population. Antibiotic usage‐related quality measures may have resulted in unintended complications and should be re‐evaluated.”
How Can We Combat C. difficile?
Another study unveiled during the October 18 press briefing addressed the ways hospitals, gastroenterologists and other health care practitioners could combat C. difficile entitled, “Aggressive Attack on C. difficile Results in Significant Decrease in Hospital Infection Rate: the INTEGRIS Baptist Medical Center Experience.”
Waging “an all out war on C. difficile,” researchers implemented a number of measures over a three‐month period at INTEGRIS Baptist Medical Center, a tertiary care facility in Oklahoma City which admits approximately 26,000 patients per year and experienced an increase in C. difficile cases.
“Aimed at reducing the incidences of C. difficile infections, these measures consisted of a multi‐faceted attack on C. difficile, including improved prevention, early detection, review and full implementation of national infection control guidelines, and aggressive treatment measures,” explained Mark H. Mellow, M.D., FACG, Center for Digestive Health, Oklahoma City, OK. “In addition to standard isolation procedures, we also elicited suggestions from physicians and nurses to best ensure compliance, such as placing a trashcan near the door to avoid traversing the room after de‐gowning; keeping an uncluttered sink area; using appropriate size gloves; and making stethoscopes easily accessible,” said Dr. Mellow.
Dr. Mellow and his team also initiated a campaign to limit proton pump inhibitor use outside of critical care units and encouraged nursing staff to send stool for C. difficile toxin (CDT) testing if C. difficile was suspected, without waiting for physician order.
“In the 12 months prior to our interventions, the incidence of CDT positive hospitalized patients was 11.3 per 100 admissions,” said Dr. Mellow. “After a 3‐month implementation period, the ensuing 12‐month positive CDT incidence fell to 6.9 per 1000 patients, a decrease in C. difficile infection incidence of 40 percent. As a result, a ‘war on C. difficile‘ can have a significant positive impact on a hospital’s rate of infection,” said Dr. Mellow.
Cutting Edge Treatments Help Patients with C. difficile
Up to 25 percent of patients will have a recurrence of C. difficile infection, and a proportion will be refractory to antibiotics. Additional therapies for this difficult‐to‐treat subpopulation include antibiotics, probiotics, toxin‐binding medications, active vaccination, intravenous immunoglobon, and fecal bacteriotherapy (FB).
“Fecal bacteriotherapy, more commonly known as fecal transplant, has been slowly gaining ground as a rescue for recurrent and refractory cases of C. difficile associated diarrhea,” said C. Brock Miller, M.D., University of North Carolina at Chapel. Dr. Miller and his research team today reported findings from their initial experience using FB via colonoscopy, “Fecal Bacteriotherapy via Colonscopy for Refractory and Recurrent Clostridium difficile Associated Diarrhea,” which showcased two patients.
The first patient, a healthy 34‐year old woman who developed CDAD after eight courses of antibiotics over six months, and had ongoing recurrences of CDAD, had an immediate improvement in symptoms and has been infection‐free for nine months after fresh stool donated from her healthy 40‐year old sister was liquefied and delivered throughout the terminal ileum and entire colon via colonoscopy.
A second patient, a healthy 50‐year old female, who also developed recurrent C. difficile toxin positive diarrhea, elected to undergo FB via colonoscopy after testing and donation by her husband. She has been cured of C. difficile associated diarrhea to date, according to Dr. Miller.
“While further clinical studies and long‐term follow‐up of patients are required, fecal bacteriotherapy appears to be a viable, safe, and inexpensive option for cases of recurrent and refractory disease,” said Dr. Miller.
The goal of another study unveiled today was to explore novel and inexpensive antimicrobial agents commonly found in nature in an effort to combat C. difficile in hospitals.
“For more than 2000 years in the Indian subcontinent, indigenous people have been using turmeric in their daily food,” explained Rattan Patel, M.D. “Traditional Indian medicine, Ayurveda, has been using this spice to help decrease the rate of gastrointestinal infection.”
In the study, “Inhibiting Hospital Associated Infection of Toxigenic Clostridium difficile Using Natural Spice – Turmeric (Curcumin),” Dr. Patel and his research team found that all strains of of C. difficile were inhibited by turmeric extract (curcumin).
“Turmeric has been shown to be relatively safe in clinical studies, with more than 40 clinical trials already performed in the United States using curcumin as an intervention as per the Clinical Trail database,” said Dr. Patel. “It’s likely that daily use of turmeric in hospital settings, in food products like curry or soup, can potentially decrease the incidence of Clostridium difficile associated diarrhea. But more studies are needed to determine the mechanism of action of turmeric and the physiological effects of turmeric in animal models of pseudomembranous colitis,” said Dr. Patel.
About the American College of Gastroenterology
Founded in 1932, the American College of Gastroenterology (ACG) is an organization with an international membership of more than 11,000 individuals from 80 countries. The College is committed to serving the clinically oriented digestive disease specialist through its emphasis on scholarly practice, teaching and research. The mission of the College is to serve the evolving needs of physicians in the delivery of high quality, scientifically sound, humanistic, ethical, and cost‐effective health care to gastroenterology patients. www.acg.gi.org